Social Security Is More Than a Monthly Benefit
Social Security is often viewed as a monthly paycheck that replaces part of the income earned during a career. As a result, many discussions focus on when to claim benefits. While the timing of that decision is important, it only scratches the surface of what Social Security contributes to a retirement plan.
The age at which you claim Social Security influences far more than the size of your monthly benefit. It affects the amount of guaranteed income available throughout retirement, the level of financial protection provided to a surviving spouse, the pressure placed on an investment portfolio during market downturns, and even the flexibility available for tax planning.
When those factors are considered together, Social Security becomes much more than a government benefit. It becomes one of the foundational building blocks of a retirement income plan, making the claiming decision less about maximizing a monthly check and more about strengthening the household's financial security over a lifetime.
Coordinating Social Security Benefits as a Couple
Each worker earns a Social Security retirement benefit based on their own earnings history. The amount is determined primarily by lifetime earnings and the age at which retirement benefits begin. While you can claim benefits as early as age 62, doing so will permanently reduce your monthly payment. For individuals who delay claiming beyond full retirement age, delayed retirement credits generally increase benefits by approximately 8% per year until age 70. Delaying benefits until age 70 provides the maximum monthly retirement benefit available based on your own earnings record.
For married couples, however, Social Security provides more than one type of benefit. Depending on individual circumstances, a spouse may also qualify for benefits based on their partner’s work record. These spousal benefits are designed to provide additional income when one spouse earned significantly less during their career or spent years out of the workforce raising children or caring for family members. The rules governing retirement, spousal, and survivor benefits are different, and eligibility depends on several factors. Couples should avoid assuming they will automatically receive the larger benefit without first understanding how the rules apply to their situation.
After one spouse dies, the rules change again. In many cases, the surviving spouse becomes eligible for a survivor benefit, allowing them to continue receiving the larger of the two retirement benefits rather than losing both sources of income. This is one of the reasons the higher-earning spouse's claiming decision often has consequences that extend well beyond their own retirement.
Because retirement, spousal, and survivor benefits each follow different rules, Social Security planning is rarely as simple as deciding when one person should begin collecting benefits. Married couples generally achieve better outcomes by coordinating their claiming decisions and evaluating how those choices affect the household's guaranteed income over both spouses' lifetimes. Rather than asking how each spouse can maximize an individual benefit, the better question is how their combined claiming decisions can create the strongest guaranteed income floor for the household. In other words, Social Security planning is not about optimizing two individual benefits. It is about building the strongest guaranteed income stream for the household over both spouses' lifetimes.
To illustrate, consider Harry and Amanda. Harry's projected retirement benefit at full retirement age is $3,000 per month, while Amanda's is $1,800 per month.
| Scenario | Household Guaranteed Income While Both Are Living | Amanda's Survivor Benefit if Harry Dies First |
|---|---|---|
| Both Claim at age 62 | Approximately $3,360/month | Approximately $2,100/month |
| Amanda Claims at 62, Harry Claims at 70 | Approximately $5,520/month (after Harry claims) | Approximately $3,720/month |
By delaying benefits until age 70, Harry increases the household's guaranteed income by approximately $2,160 per month once both benefits are in payment. It also increases Amanda's survivor benefit by approximately $1,620 per month if Harry dies first. Over a retirement lasting twenty years after Harry's death, that difference could represent well over $380,000 in additional guaranteed lifetime income before future cost-of-living adjustments.
Harry's decision to delay benefits didn't simply increase his own monthly payment. It increased the couple's guaranteed income while they were both alive and created a substantially larger survivor benefit for Amanda if she outlived him. One claiming decision strengthened the household's retirement income plan both while Harry and Amanda were living together and after Amanda became the surviving spouse.
This example illustrates why the claiming decision is often about much more than maximizing benefits for the higher-earning spouse. That does not mean delaying benefits is always the right answer. Some retirees need Social Security to meet current spending needs, while others may have health concerns or family circumstances that make claiming earlier more appropriate. The objective is not to maximize every benefit, but to determine how Social Security best supports the household's overall retirement income strategy.
Social Security Does Not Exist in Isolation
The decision of when to claim Social Security influences many other areas of retirement planning. Some retirees intentionally delay benefits while completing Roth conversions during years when taxable income is relatively low. Others rely on taxable investment accounts during the early years of retirement to allow Social Security benefits to continue growing. Households with pensions or significant investment assets often have more flexibility than those who depend on Social Security to meet immediate spending needs.
Looking at the monthly benefit in isolation rarely produces the best decision. Social Security claiming, tax planning, withdrawal strategies, investment management, and survivor planning are interconnected. Evaluating each decision independently may optimize one part of the plan while unintentionally weakening another.
Planning for an Uncertain Future
Questions about Social Security's long-term financial outlook have become increasingly common. Current projections indicate that if Congress does not replenish the retirement trust fund before its reserves are exhausted, ongoing payroll tax revenue would still be sufficient to pay a substantial majority of scheduled benefits. While the exact percentage varies across projections, it is generally expected to be around three-quarters of promised benefits.
No one knows how Congress will ultimately address the funding shortfall. Policymakers could increase payroll taxes, modify benefit formulas, raise the full retirement age, adjust income thresholds, or implement some combination of those changes. Historically, Congress has acted before significant reductions in benefits took effect, although the timing and structure of future reforms remain uncertain.
For retirees already receiving benefits or those approaching retirement, dramatic changes are generally viewed as less likely than they are for younger workers. Individuals with longer time horizons, however, should consider incorporating this uncertainty into their retirement planning. Rather than assuming benefits will remain unchanged or disappear altogether, retirees can evaluate how their retirement plan would perform if future benefits were modestly lower than currently projected. One practical approach is to stress-test the retirement plan using a modest reduction in future Social Security benefits. If the plan remains successful under that assumption, future legislative changes become less likely to disrupt long-term financial security. If the analysis identifies a gap, there is still time to increase savings, adjust retirement timing, or modify future spending assumptions.
A Foundation Worth Protecting
Social Security serves as longevity insurance, inflation protection, survivor protection, and the foundation of guaranteed retirement income all at once. Evaluating the claiming decision within the context of the broader retirement plan often produces better long-term outcomes than focusing solely on the size of the monthly check.
The decision of when to claim Social Security is rarely just about one person's monthly benefit. It is about creating the strongest foundation of guaranteed income for the household, protecting the spouse who may one day continue retirement alone, and building a plan that remains resilient even as circumstances change.
McLean Asset Management Corporation (MAMC) is a SEC registered investment adviser. The content of this publication reflects the views of McLean Asset Management Corporation (MAMC) and sources deemed by MAMC to be reliable. There are many different interpretations of investment statistics and many different ideas about how to best use them. Past performance is not indicative of future performance. The information provided is for educational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell securities. There are no warranties, expressed or implied, as to accuracy, completeness, or results obtained from any information on this presentation. Indexes are not available for direct investment. All investments involve risk.
The information throughout this presentation, whether stock quotes, charts, articles, or any other statements regarding market or other financial information, is obtained from sources which we, and our suppliers believe to be reliable, but we do not warrant or guarantee the timeliness or accuracy of this information. Neither our information providers nor we shall be liable for any errors or inaccuracies, regardless of cause, or the lack of timeliness of, or for any delay or interruption in the transmission there of to the user. MAMC only transacts business in states where it is properly registered, or excluded or exempted from registration requirements. It does not provide tax, legal, or accounting advice. The information contained in this presentation does not take into account your particular investment objectives, financial situation, or needs, and you should, in considering this material, discuss your individual circumstances with professionals in those areas before making any decisions.
